‘Not biased’: SC judge slams campaign seeking his recusal (Lead)

Must Read

Jharkhand polls for 81 constituencies from November 30 to December 20; counting on 23rd December

Addressing a press meeting today, Chief Election Commissioner Sunil Arora has announced the poll dates for Jharkhand Legislative assembly....

Congress forms six-member committee of AICC to review situation of NRC in Assam

In a bid to review the condition of Assam state after the implementation of the NRC exercise, Congress party...

Shiv Sena elects Eknath Shinde as party’s legislative leader; Sunil Prabhu appointed as chief whip of party

In a striking breakthrough, Shiv Sena elected senior minister Eknath Shinde as the party's legislative leader today. It has...
New Delhi, Oct 15 (IANS) Supreme Court judge Arun Mishra on Tuesday expressed anguish at a social media campaign and news reports seeking his recusal from a constitution bench hearing pleas linked to compensation in the Land Acquisition Act.

Justice Mishra, who is heading a five-judge bench, referring to the social media posts and news reports, said: “I am not biased… If I am satisfied that I am biased, then I can recuse myself from hearing this case.”

This issue cropped up while the apex court was hearing a clutch of petitions challenging the validity of provisions related to compensation in the Land Acquisition Act.

Insisting that he will sacrifice himself if the integrity of institution is at stake, Justice Mishra expressed unhappiness by the repetitive use of “impartial” by the parties involved in the hearing, who sought his recusal.

“This word hurts me. Don’t use it as it will send wrong message to the common man,” he said.

The bench also comprises Justices Indira Banerjee, Vineet Sharan, M.R. Shah and S. Ravindra Bhat.

Senior advocate Shyam Divan, representing some farmer associations and individuals, had registered an objection over Justice Mishra hearing the matter, and sought his recusal citing judicial propriety. Divan told the court that the bench would have to look into the verdict, which Mishra authored.

Justice Mishra was part of the verdict in February last year, which held acquisition of the land by a government agency cannot be overturned, if there was delay by land owners who fail to accept compensation within five years, citing pending court cases. In 2014, another verdict had ruled the land acquisition can be overturned if there is delay in accepting the compensation awarded against the acquisition. In March 2018, the top court had said a larger bench would look into the verdicts.

Divan told the bench that Justice Mishra had expressed his opinion in an over 100 page judgement and opined other view taken by another bench is bad in law. Therefore, a judge cannot sit over appeal of his past verdict.

Justice Mishra said: “It is not so simple. Letters are being written and there are social media posts. Articles are being written. You and I know what the issue is. I can tell you but not in open court… the institution and the Chief Justice is being maligned on social media.”

He said that it is not the appeal against the verdict in which he was the party, and if persuaded, he may change or correct his view.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for Centre said: “The prayer is not for undermining a single judge but the entire Constitution bench. The publication articles or content on social media, there is a pattern wherein two days before important matters these things appear. It intended to influence the hearing. Nobody takes social media seriously but this pattern is serious”.


Disclaimer This article is published directly through a syndicated feed and not edited by The Indian Wire staff.

- Advertisement -

Latest News

Deepika, Ranveer seek Lord Venkateswara’s blessings on 1st anniversary

Mumbai, Nov 14 (IANS) Bollywood couple Deepika Padukone and Ranveer Singh started celebrations of their first...

Venice flooded by highest tide in more than 50 years

New Delhi, Nov 14 (IANS) Venice has been hit by its highest tide in more than 50 years, leaving much of the Italian city...

Jharkhand: Ex-Maoist to contest from Maoist-infested Tamar

By Nityanand ShuklaRanchi, Nov 14 (IANS) Tamar seat situated on outskirts of Ranchi likely to witness an interesting fight in the forthcoming Jharkhand Assembly...

Taapsee Pannu: Education is solution to all problems

Mumbai, Nov 14 (IANS) Actress Taapsee Pannu believes that education is the solution to all problems.She recently shot for a Karamveer episode for the...

It’s Children’s Day and here’s a peek into the childhood of adorable Bollywood stars

November 14th calls for Children's Day and we can't keep calm. This day, let us all take a ride to the 'bachpan' of our...
- Advertisement -

More Articles Like This